I was inspired by some posts and decided to do some more experimenting on some scraps of mahogany I have with Analine dye and danish oil. Compared danish oil to shellac and there seems to be a slight difference. Danish has the same deep luster but contrasts the colors a little more in the corner I tried.
Ok, for the dye experiment. The pieces were not sealed but you'll get the idea. there at 320 and porous.
I'll compare these to the piece above so you can see the contrast:
1st Amber - Analine dye applied and Danish Oil on top:
All Three with a fresh coat. Left Red Sanded back with amber, middle natural, right is Amber, bottom is black sanded back with amber:
that slight blue hue is the danish being sucked into the wood. Use your imagination to fill in the gaps.
My conclusions are the amber really brought out the red in the mahogany. I was expecting really really gold effect but it was beautiful. In all honesty I didn't expect much from black. Its such a hard contrast compared to the other that it was really just there and I grabbed it. What took me by surprise was the rings. The Rings on the natural are light but the other with the black dye got into those spots which made those rings dark. This was something I also really liked. Finally the Red die sanded back with amber. The red sanded back added a 3D effect I've heard others talk about.
The black has an aged look to it that I don't quite think would work on this one but I really dig those rings. I think If i sanded it back more I'd keep some of the lightness.
I'm going to try all three now. Add the black, sand it way back, add the red, sand it back a little less, and then the amber.