Every headstock presents its share of compromises, advantages and disadvantages, and I'm not personally against anyone of them (except for scarf-jointed necks, they just look cheap to me). For the neck I've been working on I chose the Fender style, partly because that's a bit easier for me.
Yea... I like the straight Fender style because of simplicity... and aesthetics. I think what I might do is sorta in between... most scoops go about 1/4" down (not counting the fretboard). Since I like a 5/8" thick neck (not counting fretboard) and 1/2" is the typical headstock thickness... maybe what I'll do is just a very minor 1/8" scoop (again, not counting the fretboard).