What ever guitar forum you go to; jemsite, lespaulforum....almost everybody *HATES* good old Ed Roman. Funny thing is, that the more I learn about guitars and how they work, the more I realize.....that the stuff I've read on Ed's site seriously cuts wood.
And of course he is plugging his own guitars, but it's easy to see through that...
Most guitar companies are very conservative, you won't see Gibson come out with 25,5 scale Les Paul. Funny thing is....they have made 'm. As custom test versions. I have read posts of people seeing and playing them, and loving them.
Same with Korina bodied LPs. They are a very limited few out there, and originally they had planned them. Unfortunately the shipment of Korina didn't arrive, or importer of wood had some trouble with getting things organized, so Gibson went ahead with Mahogany LP.
The great thing with building your own copy is that you're no longer bound to the marketing departments of Gibson, Ibanez, Fender, etc.......you're only bound the limits of your imagination.
From my JS-7 built I still have slap of Korina left. And that slap just screams LP to me. Up till now I never considered a LP. I just didn't like the neck.....to thick for me...but then your mind goes wondering......hmmmm Korina body......Ibanez style neck.......hmmmmm.......korina body with korina top, or maple top, or mahogany top.....hmmm......what would work better???
Mahogany neck, or maple neck.....or even Korina neck.....Definitely Ibanez style neck shape......24 frets, 25.5" scale.....and headsape??...RG, SC, or just regular LP????
The Gibson Custom department would laugh at me when proposing stuff like this (or ask me to hand over some serious ca$h and keep it quiet.)
Isn't that the great thing of building guitars, you can make this wild ideas reality. And if everything just turns sour.......you can always burn the guitar....in the fire place, open a bottle of wine......and enjoy the flames. ;-)