Everybody slags the pistols and says they couldn't play. Honestly sit down with Never Mind the Bollocks and try to say that. There's some real good Chuck Berry hooks in there. The Rythm section is amazing. Sid couldn't play a lick, but he's not on the album. They actually hired the original bass player to play the bass on songs he's written. Sex Pistols were'nt bad musicians. No virtuosos, but they were really solid.
Some punk bands have mediocre musicians, and they can still "make it" because they've got some other charisma or something going for them. Johnny Ramone was only proficient at playing one style, but he was really good at it. I guess he was pretty rough on the first record, and the ethos is anybody can grab a guitar and you don't have to be amazing. But the idea that punk is bad musicianship on purpous is the creation of a media that doesn't understand it. That's all I was trying to say.
Rancid and the Rezillos both have unbelievable bass players. The Toy Dolls have a crazy good guitar player. Punk Rockers don't think it's cool to not know how to play. They do think it's ok to fly at it before you're perfect. Johnny Ramone made me feel more with one note than Ingwe Malmstein (sp) ever did. I guess it is more about the way a punk rock guitar player can make you feel, than technical proficiencey, but I think that works out in most popular genres.
Man you're right about the Dolls. Those dudes could play. I just saw that new Ramones movie, and the best part of it is the 10 seconds of Dolls footage.
Billy