oK, I am surrendering this top (for future backsplice?) It was a cheapie $15.00 deal and it surved its purpose, I guess,
The soundhole was cut too large
It was the wrong direction/ crappy grain ended up in lower bout area
I thinned it too thin? (003-005) Well, it could have been a light string guitar
the warping is too difficult to control at this point its all over the place.
Crack in top (This would have repaired just fine, Cracks need "stopholes" drilled in front of them, and it worked fine.)
The top flexes pretty good, I guess, I think it would be fine but for the warping and soundhole issue which would be a pain to fix anyway.
SO Ive lost a set of sides, and a top now (from the 'backup pile") Although the sides will be used for side crack strips and this top can be economicly used for backsplice. Lessons learned, no shelak topcoat for sealing (Kinkeads book), at least not as thick as I apparently put it on. I did it because the black stuff from scraping the rosette was getting into the unsealed wood, so I may do a super light seal on the upper bout only, around the sound hole area, but I may just use the drillpress to sand this stuff out in the future. I planned ahead by getting 2 of most everything for backup, didnt expect to need to USE it all up!
So far, everything is a disaster!