Greg...obviously you have never played a proper V.I play standing up with the neck angled upward and the top of the arm rest of the V body at about my waist line.this puts my picking arm hanging straight down with my hand basically right in front of my crotch(an argument could be made that for a man this is optimum hand position...hehe)
My fretting arm also hangs down straight to the elbow,where my forearm then comes up and my hand wraps perfectly around the neck...neither of my arms has to be held away from my body,as always happens with any strat shaped guitar(or anything with a forearm rest.
http://www.kxkguitars.com/
Take a look at Steve Swanson here...(my guitar is the same as the one pictured)picture the guitar hanging lower in the strap about another 8 inches to a foot,and that is me.
The guitar is actually so well balanced and comfortable that i now build all of my guitars to have the same forearm rest and neck/body join...that should tell you something.
I just feel a little sorry for you guys that only think there is just ONE ergonomically "correct" guitar for everyone.I wear 32 by 36 inch pants,and my shirts have to have a medium sized torso and extra long arms to fit me properly....most people are closer to a reversal of those dimensions(36 by 32 pants)
Is it so hard for you to crack that narrow mind open just a HAIR and realize you are not the world's definition of the perfect person?
to quote the great one..."it's easy if you try"
I was going to just gloss over your post,since in the last one you basically played the hand of "I pretend to misunderstand your post in order to take umbrage",but I did read it,and you have some good points...but what you are again doing is trying to twist my post to mean the exact opposite of what I actually said.
The entire reason I now play a V and my Exploder and nothing else is because i WAS developing wrist strain from my "forearm rest having" guitars.You see,I pick extremely fast and repetitively(think Deicide),and I get nowhere near the time for practice those guys do.so ergonomics are extremely important to me.
Drak's comments ring very true for me...everyone is obviously different.So that makes you pretty much in the wrong here,because even though you may research the "middle ground of human movement",you take into consideration none of what makes some of us very,very different.
Since i left my other guitars hanging on the wall,I have had no wrist issues.
Wes 1,ergonomic misinterpretation 0