Whew! Take a couple of days off to go play some shows and look what I almost missed. This is a VERY GOOD THREAD!
1. It answers numerous questions about "can I use (whatever cheap/accessible/mystery/ply/paper mache) to make this body"
- Seems odd though that we always talk about body material and rarely neck materials.
2. The metal crowd responds. I just got done with a whirlwind 3 show/2 day weekend of playing some of the nastiest metal, rock, shredfest type music you could ask for (even our version of Devil Went Down to Georgia) - and yes, I used my plywood bass for all but 3 songs (easier than retuning on stage) because the tone is GREAT! Our guitarists are tone freaks - in opposite directions, but tone freaks. They balked at me suggested playing a plywood instrument on stage - until it was assembled and heard. Thanks to zyonsdream for starting that thread! For some, I agree, plug it in, turn the treble all the way up and beat one chord as fast as you can, as long as I have EMG 81's and a DS-1 to support it, who cares. Fine, go burst an eardrum or two. Even Lemmy cares about his tone - but all you'll hear from him is "we're motorhead and we play rock and roll" (censored for forum use)
3. What is tone? Isn't this commonly referred to as an "eye of the beholder" thing?
I like "my" tone, you like "your" tone. There are certain scientific principles that would lead us to use one material over another for appearance or tonal quality and I can almost guarantee you that somewhere in this world, someone has made a guitar out of just about everything from recycled wal-mart bags and epoxy to laminated chipboard to the finest mahogany ever seen. To me, the only way to really know if it will work is to build it out and see what happens. If it doesn't sound good, put a piece of veneer on top to cover the holes, finish it as a clock or something. Obviously balsa or cork would be ruled out - but in this "green" era - what could we possibly do to compensate for the lack of tonal quality without making an overprocessed sound?
Certain woods have stigmas, like everything else. Chevy vs. Ford, that sort of thing. I'm not advocating an army of low quality instruments, merely the suggestion that each of us will have a completely different viewpoint of "tone", but structural integrity is a constant.
Ahhh... I feel much better now.