Brian's right - the Mod Podge glue didn't hold well to the poly finish of the V, and since I messed up the back of the neck (crooked cut lines near the binding, as well as mysterious lumps under the fabric) I had to tear it off and start over
Anyway, it was easy enough to tear off, and I've just about figured out that if you glue each piece of fabric to each other instead of the body, you can make guitar-clothes Remember the AxeSak?
Ok, so I broke out some 320 sandpaper and matted the finish of the V in preparation to start over, but while I contemplated the actual refinishing (before restarting) I decided to tackle a Warmoth Star body I've had for a few months This one's coming along (with more thought into each step than I used before), and I've just about got it nailed on how to cover the sides of the body with fabric. Obviously I can't do seamless sides because of the slits in the fabric and the curves around the body, but here's basically what I came up with (forgot to take progress pics DOH!)
Ok, so I covered the front and back first and glued those down. Following Brian's tutorial, I trimmed off the edges, which messed me up because I was not going to paint the sides like Brian did. Another problem I ran into was starting with a raw unfinished/unprimered body - natural brown/red mahogany - and using a fairly thin lightweight fabric (100% cotton). Once the glue dried, the wood color gave the white parts in the fabric a pinkish hue. So, since I had already screwed the edges, and now found that I screwed up by not using a primer coat, I decided to just slap on another layer of fabric (after sanding the first one smooth). This time I left a ton of overhang to cover the sides.
I took the rest of this trip a step at a time - glue the top down, then coat it, putting a generous amount of glue over the edges of the body onto the overhanging fabric (BEFORE I made my contour slits). This works great because when it comes time to cut the slits, the fabric is kinda rubbery and very easy to work with - and doesn't unravel if you do straight cuts!
Ok, so of course once you fold the edges over, you see bare wood. Since I'm using a patterned fabric, I just took some scraps that had a matching pattern (or close enough match) and glued them down into the curves/contours, THEN glued the top layer's overhang on top of the scrap "patch". So far, this trick is working out great.
The only trouble I expect at this point is doing the rounded points - those will have to be cut and folded carefully
But then, I don't mind a few lumps in it as I should be able to build up the top coat of Mod Podge to blend them in smoothly.
Also, I'm using the Matte finish Mod Podge - I used the Gloss Coat MP before, and it still felt tacky after a few days, even when sanded smooth. So far the Matte MP hasn't tackied up since I sanded it.
Newc