Olympic® Interior Oil Based Stain.
is that one of those stain & protect, all in one finishes designed for floors, stairs, handrails, furniture etc? If so, you're using the wrong type of stain for the effect that you're trying to achieve.
Read through this article: http://www.stewmac.com/tradesecrets/bridge...e_guitar01.html
it should give you a better idea of how to finish a guitar & the kind of products that you should be using. Once you've read through that, search the forums for finishing, staining, sunbursts, dyes etc...anything that is relivant to what you want to achieve. Then, if you're serious about getting a good finish & want to know what finishes will work together, buy Bob Flexnor's book on wood finishes.