I never said I've mastered Solid Body builds!
Perhaps not, but the rest of us say it!
SR
My opinion is this.
Anyone who "thinks" they have mastered luthiery needs to step back and take a reality check. Their ego is getting in the way of reality. There is always something new to learn or an area that is still to be explored. Solid Bodies, Hollow bodies, Acoustics, Semi's, Ukes, Violins, this type of paint, that type of paint, this type of binding, that type of binding. There is ALWAYS something to learn. Unfortunately in every field there are those who have an inflated ego, they think they are either the best or amongst the best. But what is "The Best", it's subjective, as to what one thinks is awesome there is another that won't touch it.
If a person genuinely feels this, that they are either the best or among the best, chances are they are delusional and their narcissism is blurring their vision. It doesn't matter what field you practice, be it art, sport, music, whatever, the same principal applies. Unfortunately in luthiery, we have the same. Builders out there that have massively inflated egos. In some cases the internet can turn them into forum trolls. In some cases the person may build a good instrument, in other cases they fall far from that tree, but it's not so much to do with the instrument but their attitude. If the person is a genuine, good natured and down to earth person, then they won't have this ego problem.
A friend of mine is a retired luthier. I call him a "Master Luthier", he says he hates the term and doesn't even call himself a luthier. When I sit in his workshop and look at the photo's and "thank you's" on the wall, its like a hall of fame. Some of our countries biggest (and international) artists are on that wall and I'm talking all walls of the entire workshop covered in photo's after a 40 year building career. His guitars are flawless. I see the work he does and cannot even imagine getting to that level myself. When we first met he asked to see my work and me being embarrassed at that thought suggested I'm just a guy who tinkers in his shed. His reply was "That's all I am"! My response was "yeah, but I don't have have people flying from all over the world to pick up their guitars". He responded with a shrug and something along the lines of when I've been doing it as long as he has I will.
Long story short - NO-ONE has mastered Luthiery. There is always something to learn and the learning will stop if you have an ego.