I keep hearing more and more about how it wears off. A vicious cycle : You want your new neck to look old, so you quickly make it look old, but then from wear, it starts to look more new in places. Maybe eventually it looks so weird, you buff all the shoe polish out, then it really looks new, more new than if you would have just treated it like a regular guitar and got honest wear during that time.
And what does one get out of making a guitar look old right away ?
"check it out, looks vintage don't it ? "
"Hell yeah, looks real old"
"yeah, been sitting here thinking about how vintage it looks"
"yeah, real cool vintage look"
" think it needs to look even more vintage ? "
"not sure, maybe we need to look at pics of real vintage guitars"
"I already spent 6 hours today doing that"
"oh, well guess you better leave it be then. How does it play ?"
" not sure, never played it. Afraid it might take away from the vintage look".