I don't think anybody's been particularly harsh - if I was perceived as harsh or demeaning, I certainly apologize, but I think you guys are still missing the point. Reading the very first post, we find the following:
Now, I know that a lot of you adjust your volume from the guitar, but given the intrinsic nature of a passive electric guitar with magnetic pickups, I'd be willing to wager that not one of you regularly plays his guitar with the volume set between 1 and 2 (nor 4 and 5, for that matter), and on the off chance that you do, you're losing enough high end to obscure the actual sound of your pickups - that's a simple fact of life. Everyone is entitled to use his equipment his own way, but some methods cause unintended side-effects that users need to be made aware of. 'Nuff said! Of course, fi you're running EMGs, none of the preceding applies to you, so you can ignore it.
The other thing that nobody (including me) has even considered is the fact that if the old pots were linear taper and the replacements are audio taper, the 4-5 range on the new pots is about the same as the 1-2 range on the old ones. Since Gibson is notorious for using linear volume pots, that's a fairly likely scenario. vpcnk, do you know what the taper of those pots is?