My cousin bought a Les Paul a while ago that was awfull. But he's always wanted a Les Paul ever since he got to play mine & so just bought one thinking it would compare favourably. It did not.
His needed a partial fret job, a new nut, a replacement bridge & in my opinion a new fretboard. Some of the chunks taken out of it were disgracefull. I would not have allowed one of my own guitars out of the shop like that if you put a gun to my head.
The problem was that it was the only one he liked to look of in the shop. There were others there that were excellent, Including a blue burst thing with p90's that was an animal. He bought the wrong one against my advice. He was lucky he had a family member that could sort all his problems for free.
But I have to say, Gibson get a hammering for their guitars from a lot of people. I see (hear) a lot of crap about them & thats exactly what most of it is, Crap. The majority of their guitars are good quality, Once you set them up to your own personal playing style they are a thing of beauty. I have noticed over the years that most of the guys bashing them are Fender players who have never even touched a Gibson, & vice versa. Kinda like the whole "my car's faster than your car" thing
Personaly. I love Les Pauls, Best guitars Iv ever played from a factory. Its an awful shame when one comes along & ruins that view, but it does occasionaly happen. At least this one got to a decent guitar guy who could salvage it & make it live up to its reputation.