Yes, and Dan Armstrong made a granite guitar for the Fender research department in the 70’s. I don’t get your point.
And don’t get us wrong. We are NOT putting you down, just giving you some advices. We love guitar building and think that you should try it out. If you think that this course thing is right for you, go ahead.
But I think Mickguard expressed it very well when he noticed that you can get yourself a shop full of the necessary tools AND the wood you need to build a couple of guitars for the money you are planning on spending on that one guitar. And you also have 3 years to build those guitars.
I’m curious. Have you actually spoken to some of the earlier participants in real live, or have you read their comments online? I have a hard time to believe that those instruments showed online is made in 2 ½. Remember that the finish has to cure for a week if you are using water borne finish and some FIVE WEEKS if you are using nitro. I can’t get the timeline together. Are they using UV-curing finishes? I’m suspecting that those guitars are made over several courses and not only one. Pls be aware of this so that you don’t get fooled/disappointed.
Wood and sound is something that we have debated a lot in this forum. We are good at giving advices about things like this, but you must remember that it is all PERSONAL OPINIONS. IMHO walnut isn’t at all very “maple-ish”. If you want the sound of maple, use maple. You say that you would like a “fenderish” sound. What guitar is made out of a mahogany body/maple top? A Les Paul (OK, with a mahogany neck) How do LPs sound? Not very “fenderish”, eh? I have built a guitar with mahogany body, maple top, laminated maple neck, ebony fretboard and a soapbar at the bridge. Forget about “fenderish” tone in that guitar. And it was a bolt-on! Use a set neck and you will move that sound even more into the LP range.
I wouldn’t say that the woods are fighting each other, tone-vice. Maybe you just end up with something that doesn’t sound like you wanted. That is why so many of us stress this point: Get some tools, build a couple of guitars, get experience of how wood work together to form sound and THEN build your dream guitar.