i play sepultura,overkill,pantera,slayer just about everyday
and i can promise you body wood makes almost no differance
i have many guitars almost all are "super strats"
two mahogony,one basswood,one alder,one ash
and one maple...yes i said maple and yes it weighs a ton
the maple is bright the mahogony is kinda of mid rangey
i dont know how to describe the ash other than woody sounding
the rest are kinda in between and sound almost the same
the big differances are my pickups
Duncan jb's can get heavy as hell. lots of harmonics
and clean when you roll the volume back
a Dimarzio double whammy. lots of mids and even more with the jackson mid boost
i use in this one. i can not get a thrash sound with this setup
but its creamy as hell in my B.C Rich
ive never tried Emg's but look at all the players who use them
and get very heavy sounds
therefore my two cents says its the pickups not the wood
hot pickups = hotter sounds
medium output = softer
and i am constantly changing pickups from one guitar to another
trying to get "my own sound"