Yeah yeah, keep talking out of your ass. At one time, I owned 3 strats. One with a 24.75" scale, one with 25" scale and one with a 25.5". I even tried the same pickups in all, and the difference in the scale was quite noticable in the tone between the 3 guitars, but I wasn't even trying to do an experiment with those guitars. I already knew how a *different scale affects the string tension and resonance of a guitar*. If I'm one of the few here that do, then Sheesh, we got a forum chuck full of ignorance.
I'm with you and I agree with you. I started playing with guitars in 1969 I started repairing them in late 1970 as an apprentice. I opened my own shop in 1974. I think by now I know that scale length definitely has a huge effect on tone and string tension. Not to mention pick-up placement, pick-up adjustment too, bridges and choice of wood. Fingerboards and neck material make a huge difference as well. None of these things mentioned has more effect on tone than scale length and string gauge.
"On pick-up adjustment" especially exposed pole single coil pick-ups to get a clean tone with unaffected true harmonics you must keep the pick-up lowered on the bass side. The string diameters on the bass strings do not require that the pick-up be as close as the treble side. If you don't believe that adjust them as high as possible and try to get a clear reading on a strobe-tuner on the bass strings...it won't happen period. The magnetic field will screw with the motion of the strings and make the guitar sound out of tune as the notes decay if you hit a power chord...clean or distorted.