I really wish this site was like Slashdot so we could mod stuff as 'Flamebait' with zero points...
Optical pickups are nothing new. They've been around for a while for basses and such. The problem is that your so-called perfection is pure hype. No pickup system is perfect. For all intents and purposes, piezo pickups could be considered "perfect" because they can pick up vibrations outside of the human audial envelope even better than the best optical pickup. The problem is they sound harsh and boomy unless you put them through some sort of preamp equalization process.
Optical pickups are going to be the same way. They aren't going to sound like traditional magnetic pickups, which is the sound most people want, and you're going to have to spend a hell of a lot of money and time trying to get them to sound like magnetic pickups rather than just going out and buying a Les Paul.
If you want to make music with a guitar synth, go for it. But don't call others close-minded simply because they want nothing to do with an unproven system that isn't going to give them anything they really needed, anyway.
I'm starting to get a vision of your guitar as a flat piece of graphite with an optical bridge/pickup setup, untapered neck, no truss rod, fanned frets, no nut, and some kind of reinvention of the Steinberger or LSR tuners. And it's still going to sound and play like a piece of crap nobody wants. Ned Steinberger already went through this in the '80s, don't follow his path!!
BTW, modeling amps sound like crap. Might as well just get a Flock of Seagulls hairdo and learn how to play a whole song with one finger on the keyboard.